Do You Find a Literary Prejudice against the Fantasy Genre?

Literary Prejudice

Journey photo credit: paul bica via photopin cc

Literary prejudice is an ugly thing.

Years ago I took a night course on short story writing.  (And you may say that while I might have taken it, it didn’t take in my writing.  But whatever.)

My teacher was very able.  (She would say, “Don’t use that word ‘very’ or have too many parenthetical asides.”  But whatever.) 

However she was steeped in the tradition of southern women literature.  That’s about as far as you can get from fantasy and science fiction.

Literary Prejudice

Southern Literature photo credit: leep via photopin cc

It’s difficult to put Scarlett O’Hara in a space ship or riding a dragon.  The hoop skirt is too cumbersome.  Fiddle-de-de.

Furthermore, any modern woman from the south would rather be caught wearing white shoes after Labor Day than be seen with anything as unseemly as an alien or a hobbit.

I asked my teacher toward the end of the weeks if she would read what little I had written in my fantasy novel.  At that time it wasn’t much to read, and frankly looking back on it, the thing was a mess.  But I wanted some feed back. 

Here’s what I got:  “No, I won’t read it.  That’s not my genre.”

What did that mean?  I have a feeling if my book had been a detective story or a high seas adventure or a contemporary love triangle, she would have at least glanced at it.  But not fantasy.   Is there such a thing as literary prejudice?

Which brings me to my thought:  There are many genres but there are only two kinds of writing, the good and the bad.

If Jane Austen were now alive and writing science fiction, wouldn’t her aliens be just as engaging while getting engaged? 

If Charles Dickens had written in any other genre, wouldn’t he still construct memorable minor characters with those amazing names?

If Mark Twain had taken up another genre, wouldn’t his work include his folk humor?

If Leo Tolstoy put his pen to a space trilogy, wouldn’t it have been as long as War & Peace?  For that matter, it might have been called War & Peace.

So, I think, my fantasy and science fiction friends, that we are the stepchildren of the literary world.

O, the literati like the money that comes with a big success, like Harry Potter, Star Wars, or Hunger Games.

But really… sit down and read it?  Don’t let’s be foolish!

Be Sociable, Share!

, , , , , , , , , ,

Comments

  1. Lucy Wright September 7, 2013 #

    haha love it! I think there is a huge prejudice against fantasy and sci-fi. Even though i know better I have in the back of my mind when I pick up a fantasy novel “this will be fun…but not good” But that’s not true!

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Is Magic Necessary in Fantasy? | Drew Ellenwood - October 5, 2013

    […] Because whether having magic or not, most fantasies do have something supernatural.  And so it is with Curious Origins of a Restless […]

  2. A Classic Christmas Fantasty... By Dickens! | Drew Ellenwood - December 4, 2013

    […] But you mostly don’t think of Charles Dickens. […]

  3. Starting a Fantasy Novel The Moment That Is Different | Drew Ellenwood - January 21, 2014

    […] course, Jane Austen is not a fantasy writer.  Ah, that she had been!  However, her most famous novel is a classic […]

  4. 3 Fantasy Christmas Movies for the Family | Drew Ellenwood - January 28, 2014

    […] insides of chimneys and Whoville.  People like these things in December whether or not they hold a prejudice against fantasy the rest of the […]

  5. 5 Essential Traits of Fantasy Heroes and Heroines | Drew Ellenwood - February 1, 2014

    […] fantasy readers want a champion we can root for, suffer with, struggle alongside, and ultimately cheer on.  If our […]

  6. 7 Classic Fantasy Novels | Drew Ellenwood - February 1, 2014

    […] This is my list of essential fantasy novels.  Don’t like it – make your own list or leave a comment.  I like to hear from you and discuss the wonderful world of fantasy. […]

  7. Romance in Fantasy and Science Fiction | Drew Ellenwood - February 14, 2014

    […] it:  As genres go, fantasy and science fiction do not lend themselves well to […]

  8. MythQuest: A Review of a Science Fantasy Series | Drew Ellenwood - April 26, 2014

    […] Recently on Netflix I caught a Canadian TV series called MythQuest.  Its first and only season was shown in 2001.  As a science fantasy, MythQuest falls within the purview of our consideration as fantasy and science fiction fans. […]

  9. Unbelievable Stories in Fantasy and Science Fiction | Drew Ellenwood - April 29, 2014

    […] I’m Lucy, your guest blogger for today.  A while ago Drew talked about how in the fantasy and sci-fi genre there are pills you must swallow to buy into the story and truly enjoy it.  Well, I’m here to […]

  10. What If? The Story Idea as a First Step to Publishing | Drew Ellenwood - May 21, 2014

    […] Pride and Prejudice – what if a man of good fortune did move into a neighborhood with too many eligible ladies?  Or if you’re more cynical, what if a woman could marry for love and money? […]

  11. 3 Independence Day Movies for the Family | Drew Ellenwood - July 3, 2014

    […] this blog isn’t about fantasy or science fiction, though we’ll touch on these.  I’m giving you three Independence Day movies […]

  12. Science Fantasy? What Hybrid Is That | Drew Ellenwood - July 9, 2014

    […] Science fantasy is a work of fiction that has elements of science fiction mixed with fantasy. […]

  13. Fantastic Appearance of the Human Body | Drew Ellenwood - August 2, 2014

    […] Fantasy and science fiction fans are accustomed to extraordinary beings.  We expect such things.  Star Trek introduced an alien race of blue bipeds.  Farscape one upped them with a sentient species of blue plants.  How’s that for fantastic?  Creatures with tentacles, tails, and antennae have parade by.  The general human body is boring. […]

  14. A Non-Nerd Primer | Drew Ellenwood - January 13, 2016

    […] interesting things happening to interesting characters is the key to an interested reader.  The genres of fantasy and science fiction are no exceptions.  Rather they are the […]

Leave a Reply